• Best sellers

Best Sellers

Filter
Tastefully Olive Coratina extra virgin olive oil bottle with green olives, bread, and a bowl of oil against a coastal backdrop. Tastefully Olive Coratina olive oil and Traditional dark balsamic bottles with bread, cheese, tomatoes, olives, and a dipping bowl.

Coratina Extra Virgin Olive Oil — Puglia, Italy
$26.95
Tastefully Olive Greek Seasoning infused olive oil bottle with lemon halves, fresh herbs, olives, and white cheese on marble. Tastefully Olive Greek Seasoning infused olive oil bottle with a black label and gold cap on a white background.

Greek Seasoning Infused Olive Oil
$23.95
Default Title Tastefully Olive Koroneiki olive oil and Fig dark balsamic bottles with figs, bread, cheese, and a dipping bowl overlooking the sea.

Fig Dark Balsamic Vinegar
$21.95
Default Title Olive oil poured from a Tastefully Olive bottle over zucchini, peppers, and cherry tomatoes in a cast-iron skillet.

Picual Extra Virgin Olive Oil
$24.95
Tastefully Olive Raspberry dark balsamic bottle with raspberries, mint, olive branches, and cheese drizzled with balsamic. Tastefully Olive Garlic olive oil and Raspberry dark balsamic bottles with garlic, raspberries, and cheese drizzled with balsamic.

Raspberry Dark Balsamic Vinegar
$21.95

Start your Tastefully Olive discovery with our Best Sellers collection. Browse the selection below to find something for everyday cooking, a new pairing, or a thoughtful gift.

Find your starting point

For everyday meals: Look for flavors that complement the dishes you cook most often. Check each product’s tasting notes and suggested uses for inspiration.

For dipping and dressings: Explore olive oil and balsamic combinations that suit your palate. Try a familiar flavor first, or choose something new to serve with bread or whisk into a vinaigrette.

For gifting: Consider the recipient’s favorite flavors and cooking style. Check the product page for bottle sizes, what’s included, and available purchase options.

Compare the product details below to choose your next kitchen favorite.